“How Long Has This Been Going On?” by Ethan Mordden

How Long Has This Been Going On? by Ethan Mordden is an ambitious, sweeping and panoramic 600 page epic novel that traces LGBT history over a 40+ year span through the lives of a broad cast of characters. The story opens in 1949 at Thriller Jill’s, a Los Angeles gay nightclub where patrons needed to be very discreet; it concludes with the 1991 New York City Gay Pride Parade. Along the way, the story takes the reader to San Francisco, small-town Minnesota and New Hampshire, and of course covers the 1969 Stonewall riots and AIDS.

I came out as a gay man in 1976 and have certainly seen a huge attitudinal change toward gay men and lesbians in the mindset of American culture during my life. I am also old enough to know how repressive American culture was to the LGBT community during the post World War II era and for many years thereafter. Mordden does an impressive job describing just how bleak that world was and how hard the fight was to accomplish the changes many of us today take for granted.

The author introduces us to a cast of wonderfully drawn and very diverse characters. Most notable among them:

  • Frank, the closeted vice cop at the story’s beginning, who later becomes a gay porno star. He is one of the novel’s most memorable characters.
  • Lois, the no-nonsense lesbian owner of Thriller Jill’s and her eventual partner Elaine. Elaine is married when we first meet her and eventually becomes a successful writer.
  • Luke and Tom ” the Twins”, childhood friends from small-town Minnesota whose lives become complicated when sexual longings begin to color their relationship.
  •  Luke and Tom’s close female friend Chris, the primary straight character in the story. She later moves to New York and achieves fame.
  • Walt, Tom’s nephew who grows from a young boy to a grown man.
  • Blue a teenage hustler from West Virginia.
  • and the unforgettable Johnny the Kid, the charismatic, cocky & talented singer/cabaret performer who in Chapter 1 is a 17 year-old and is approaching 60 by the time the story ends.

Many other fascinating characters are introduced throughout the book. Some both major and minor perish along the way; others survive to the end. There is an ever-shifting change of focus from one chapter to the next as the reader is regularly introduced to new individuals. In the hands of someone less skillful this shifting perspective might get muddled; Mordden however succeeds in making it work. He  uses a good mix of humor, sadness and pathos, infusing a sense of life and realism to the story as we join him and his characters in their journeys.

The opening sentence sets the stage for giving the reader the sense that one is looking back from the present to a distant time and place. “In the days when men were men and women adored them, there was a club called Thriller Jill’s on a side street off Hollywood Boulevard”. While primarily told from the third person POV, periodically this changes and it gradually becomes apparent that this is one person’s recollections of these events. That person’s identity is not revealed until the last pages.

While a long book, I never found myself wishing it would end. Each character’s story is fascinating and how their collective lives become intertwined made me want to keep reading. For anyone trying to understand the sea of change that happened within the LGBT community over this time period you need look no further than here. This was clearly one of the best books I read in 2014.

4 thoughts on ““How Long Has This Been Going On?” by Ethan Mordden

  1. Thanks for bringing this book to my attention. I had never heard of it before. It sounds like a fascinating read. I have another historical in my TBR stack that starts in the same era this one does so I think this will give me a firm foundation for that book.


    • Mel: Glad to hear you liked my review. I’m curious what the other book is. Perhaps Like People in History: A Gay American Epic by Felice Picano? If so I read that also and will be posting a review of it in the near future. I enjoyed that as well, although not as much as Mordden’s work. I have a backlog of reviews to post.

      Here’s to Good Reading and Great Writing!



      • The book I have is a prequel to a short series by Michael Rupured (After Christmas Eve). It’s a light read set mostly in the time frame of the Stonewall riots. I like to read historical novels particularly from the POV of every day people. I also gravitate to the longer, more involved works. I picked up this book yesterday and am hoping I find time to read it soon. I proofread for a publisher of gay fiction so I don’t get a lot of time for discretionary reading (The proofreading is in addition to my regular every day job and volunteer work that I do).

        I always enjoy your reviews and am looking forward to reading your backlog.

        Have a great day.



  2. Mel:

    I am so glad you enjoy my reviews. My goal is to write one a week; sometimes I achieve that and other times I miss it by a mile. I recently decided to book a weekly appointment in my online calendar to help ensure that I meet that objective. I read that Monday mornings are the best time to post a blog. I don’t know how true that is but that’s my target day & time for now.

    You remarked that you enjoy historical novels, especially longer ones. I have a doozy of one right now I’m reading, As Meat Loves Salt by Maria McCann. It’s a 565 page story of two men who meet and fall in love in 1645 while fighting in Oliiver Cromwell’s New Model Army. It certainly is not a conventional love story and one that is quite brutal. I am only half way through it but suspect this is not one that is going to have a happily ever after ending.

    Here’s to Good Reading and Great Writing!



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s